2006 was a disappointing year in music. Or maybe I’m just getting old.
2006 was at least a year of change. Just look at Pitchfork’s annual list of the top 10 albums or Metacritic’s top 30. The familiar bands that have dominated my musical universe these last few years–Wilco, Radiohead (Thom York, alone, doesn’t count), Spoon, Modest Mouse et al.–were all absent. And the others that did put out albums— Flaming Lips, I’m talking to you here— were just disastrous disappointments. Instead, the critics’ top picks are filled with new and unfamiliar names, Scott Walker?, Boris?, TV on the Radio?—all acts I’d never heard of before 2006.
And it’s not that I didn’t try new things. TV on the Radio, Band of Horses, Phoenix, Cat Power, Cold War Kids, I tried them all. And, to be fair, each has their shining moments, that one song– invariably the first song you’d hear off the album—that would make you say, “$%#^$%$ YEAH!” And for that, each deserves an honorable mention because each shows some real promise for the future. But none of their albums was consistently strong.
In contrast, there was Tapes ‘n’ Tapes’ The Loon, which suffered from a similar yet opposite affliction: pretty much the whole album, song-for-song, is consistently good… but not great. The best songs on The Loon are nowhere as near as good as the best song on the other of my honorable mentions. But, the worst songs on The Loon are by far better than the mediocrity that fills the rest of my honorable mentions.
And so, this year, for my best albums list, I could do only muster two: one familiar band and one new artist.
1. Belle and Sebastian, The Life Pursuit. When I first reviewed this album, I called it “a disappointing follow-up” to Dear Catastrophe Waitress. Now, I wonder, what I was thinking. I still think I’m right, that Dear Catastrophe was a harbinger of a new B&S sound, and that The Life Pursuit was this new sound in full fruition. But, hey, this new sound is really great. It would be stupid to think that B&S could go back to their If You’re Feeling Sinister-era sound. And they would be stupid for them to try to. Instead, The Life Pursuit reflects a new, mature, and confident B&S. But the band is still playful, creative. And as for those “unforgiveable” songs that managed to make it onto The Life Pursuit? At least, (a) they’re few. Moreover, (b) it’s their constant willingness to experienment within familiar confines that has made B&S a still rewarding band for now over a decade.
2. Joanna Newsome, Ys. I don’t normally like female vocalists. And Joanna Newsom is not really an exception. In fact, her music is not really my cup of tea. It’s broody; it’s pretentious. It’s stringy; it’s harpy. But, it’s also a novelty. The songs on Ys are incredibly complicated and rich. They compliment the listener’s intelligence (which is, frankly, probably why I like it.) The best music I think expresses latent ideas in new ways, and I’m not sure that Ys falls into that category. But it is a refreshing and impressive attempt to do something new, and worth the listener’s listen.
As for 2007, things promise to pick. Although the Shins’ new album, which will be released this January ain’t all that great– a step back from their first pair– releases by Radiohead, Wilco, and Arcade Fire should put me squarely back into a familar place: listening to thoughtful, rewarding, and good music.